Thursday, September 22, 2005

Some call for banning drivers from cell phones


By Chad Lawhorn
Lawrence Journal World

Rebecca Osladil, who works for a local radio station, spends a lot of time on her cell phone calling customers. Traffic safety commissioners will discuss outlawing cell phone usage while driving within Lawrence city limits.
Driver’s education class didn’t teach Bob Lewis how to deal with this.

“I think the only time I have ever had a real close call in a car, it has been when some other motorist is paying more attention to their cell phone than to their driving,” said Lewis, a Lawrence resident and retired Kansas University employee. “I felt like I had to do something partially in self-defense.”

What Lewis did was complain to the city’s Traffic Safety Commission. As a result, traffic safety commissioners will soon discuss a proposal to ban all drivers in the city limits from using a cell phone.

Lewis didn’t propose a specific ordinance, but said he would like for a ban to also prohibit the use of hands-free or speaker cell phones because research shows they’re just as dangerous.
“Driving really demands your total attention,” Lewis said. “Your mind can’t really be on another subject.”
Several other communities and states agree. In 2001, New York banned cell phone use by drivers statewide. Since then, 10 other states and the District of Columbia have implemented some sort of cell phone ban — some prohibiting their use by all drivers and others putting phones off-limits only to novice drivers.
This week, the National Transportation Safety Board urged all states to ban novice drivers from using wireless phones.
David Strayer — a psychology professor at the University of Utah who has conducted more than 20 research studies on cell phones and driver safety — said the science behind the bans was solid.
“The risks are quite substantial,” Strayer said, noting that many studies have found the risk of an accident increases fourfold when a driver is on a cell phone.
Sgt. Dan Ward, a spokesman with the Lawrence Police Department, doesn’t have any formal study to fall back on, but he’s pretty sure cell phone usage does cause a problem on Lawrence streets.
“I know there are a lot of drivers with a cell phone up to their ear,” Ward said. “Any time you are trying to do something other than paying full attention to driving, it can cause an accident.”
Several traffic safety commissioners on Wednesday said they wanted to learn more about the issue but worried the ordinance could be difficult to enforce.
“There’s no reason to do it if you can’t enforce it,” said Carol Bowen, a traffic safety commissioner. “If you can’t enforce it, that would just create frustration.”
Ward said enforcement would rely on police officers observing a driver using a cell phone, which he said was not much different from viewing a person running a traffic light.
A study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found that in the months after the implementation of the New York ban, the rate of drivers talking on cell phones fell from 2.3 percent to 1.1 percent. But one year later, the rate had risen back to 2.1 percent.
Danny Drungilas, another traffic safety commissioner, said the city might be able to consider other options. He suggested increasing the fines for any driver who was using a cell phone during an accident.
“Whatever we would do probably would be pretty controversial,” Drungilas said.
Driver reaction was mixed.
“I guess I would kind of agree with it because I know that when I do it, I’m a bit distracted,” said Jeff Hansen, a Topeka resident who was in downtown. “If it would stop someone from running into me, I would be for it.”
The city of Lawrence is considering a law prohibiting cell phone use while driving. What do you think about the law?
We need the law because talking on a cell phone while driving is dangerous.
We don't need such a law. It's just another example of government telling us what we can and cannot do.
Hands-free units and speaker phones should be allowed.
I don't care.
Heather Lancaster, a Lawrence resident, said she thought any future ban wouldn’t be taken very seriously by residents.
Beverly Purcell, an agent with Lawrence-based Allen and Purcell Insurance, said the insurance industry was beginning to frown on cell phone usage by drivers. Strayer, the researcher, said he believed that cell phone usage may some day become a factor in how companies set insurance rates.
“I don’t think a cell phone creates any more of a problem than a billboard that is tough to read or a road sign that is not real well placed,” Purcell said. “All of them require you to take your eyes off the road and divert your attention. I think these bans are a bit of a fad and people are just picking on cell phones.”


Blogger Snoop said...

I would not be for the smoking ban, or for a ban on cell phones. However, the reason I am for both type of bans is because of the morons who have absolutely no consideration for the safety of well being for those around them.
I have almost been hit 3 times by people on cell phones. It not only should be outlawed but stiff fines should be imposed.
It just like smokers. I would not care if someone lit up occasionally in a bar but when these people are so inconsiderate as to chain smoke in a restaurant while people are dining that is what these various municipalities target with these ordinances.
If there were any signs that people would become more responsible then this would not be an issue. But one life is not worth some idiot having a conversation about the latest school crush.

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I was headed out of town on K-10 one day, and was pulled up at the Harper stoplight. The chick in the car next to me was having one of those life-altering crisis calls--screaming, mascara-blackened tears streaming down her cheeks, shaking her head "no, no, no" with hair whipping about, punching the steering wheel, the whole bit. She took off like a shot when the light turned green; I pulled into a gas station for a couple of minutes to let her get good and far ahead of me. I hope she crashed, I just didn't want to be in on it.

Blogger Snoop said...

That is an excellent point!
Not all phone conversations are “pleasant” they can be emotional and stressful.
Even if the conversation is with some girl arguing with her boyfriend, hell we all have had those conversations. Is that call worth someone dying?

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Looking for information and found it at this great site... » »

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have been looking for sites like this for a long time. Thank you! video editing programs


Post a Comment

<< Home